Skip to main content
Free Consultation No Win, No Fee

Other Driver Hit My Rental Car: Who Pays for Damages?

When another driver hits your rental car, the situation should be straightforward—their insurance should pay. However, rental company practices can complicate matters. Here's how to handle it.

No Win, No Fee
24/7 Available
Free Consultation

When the Other Driver Is At Fault

If another driver caused the accident:

• Their liability insurance should pay for all damages
• You shouldn't have to pay for vehicle damage
• Your injuries are covered by their insurance
• You shouldn't owe the rental company

However, the rental company may still come after you initially.

What the Rental Company May Do

Even when you're not at fault, the rental company may:

• Charge your card for damages
• Claim you owe loss of use
• Expect you to collect from the other driver
• Pursue you until paid

Understanding this helps you respond appropriately.

Protecting Yourself When Not At Fault

Steps to take:

• Get thorough documentation at the scene
• Get police report naming other driver at fault
• Report to other driver's insurance immediately
• Inform rental company of the other driver's info
• Don't pay charges that should be other driver's responsibility
• Consider hiring an attorney to handle claims

Frequently Asked Questions

Can the rental company charge me even if I'm not at fault?

They may try. Your rental agreement may authorize charges. However, these can be disputed and you can pursue the at-fault driver for reimbursement.

What if the other driver won't admit fault?

Police reports and evidence establish fault regardless of what the other driver says. An attorney can help prove liability.

Why Choose Our Rental Car Accident Lawyers?

All Major Rental Companies

Experience with Enterprise, Hertz, Avis, Turo, and more

Insurance Expertise

We navigate complex insurance coverage issues

No Upfront Costs

You pay nothing unless we win your case

National Coverage

Handle out-of-state accident claims

Don't Let Insurance Companies Take Advantage of You

Our experienced rental car accident attorneys will fight for the compensation you deserve.

Call (818) 482-2260 Now