Road Defect Accident Evidence: What to Preserve
A road-defect investigation needs an exact location and an actual condition, not just “a pothole on the highway.” Identify lane, direction, route and nearby landmarks; then ask whether the road is state, city, county or private. California public-property law also asks how a dangerous condition caused harm and whether a public entity created it or had qualifying notice. A repaired roadway can leave useful records, but a later photo should be labeled as later.
Hurt Advice editorial guide. Source review: . This guide does not state that the attorney authored, reviewed or approved it. Visit the profile for public licensing and background records.
Review the attorney’s public background, then confirm experience and availability directly.
Raffi Naljian
Founder, Civil Litigation, Personal Injury & Criminal Defense Attorney
Raffi Garabed Naljian is the founder of Naljian Law Offices and an active California attorney under State Bar #238919. A Los Angeles Times profile says he founded the firm in 2008 after beginning his legal career in 1997, and the State Bar lists personal injury, litigation, criminal law, and business law among his self-reported practice areas.
View Raffi Naljian's full verified profilePrimary identity record
Learn more about Raffi Naljian
This is a focused supporting page. Use Raffi Naljian's full sourced attorney profile as the primary identity record for biography, role, languages, office information, and public-record links. Review that profile alongside the issue-specific preparation and public sources below.
The State Bar record lists Raffi Garabed Naljian as an active California attorney, State Bar #238919. Hurt Advice is a separate referral and legal information service, not the attorney's law firm.
How to Evaluate Attorney Fit for This Issue
Use this worksheet to direct a location and record search. Counsel can evaluate the correct entity, government-claim procedure and whether design, maintenance or a temporary hazard is the relevant issue. The guide does not decide whether the condition was legally dangerous.
Consultation worksheet
Road segment, controller and notice worksheet
For each source, record its custodian, relevant date and unresolved gap. Do not enter or stand in traffic to take measurements.
There is no submit or save action. Copy your notes before leaving this page.
Which original dashcam or safe photo shows lane, direction, route and defect? Is a postmile or landmark available, and could the location be mistaken?
Which official map or agency response assigns maintenance of that segment to Caltrans, a city, county or private owner?
Who holds earlier complaints, inspections and work orders? Which record predates the event rather than a later repair?
Are official plans or as-builts relevant to a design question, or is the claimed hazard a later deterioration? What expert question remains?
Which entity and incident date govern the possible government claim? Has counsel checked the actual procedural deadline and exceptions?
Sources for this guide
- California Government Code section 835
Public-property dangerous-condition elements: causation plus entity creation or notice, subject to the statutory conditions.
- California Government Code section 835.2
Actual and constructive notice framework; an incident-time observation alone does not establish prior notice.
- California Government Code section 911.2
Public-entity claim presentation periods; the proper entity, claim type and exceptions must be checked individually.
- Caltrans: Pothole and damage claims
Explains why exact state-highway location, dangerous condition and prior knowledge matter; Caltrans does not handle city or county roads.
- Caltrans: Postmile Query Tool
Official route and postmile tool for locating a state-highway segment; output should be checked against the actual scene.
What to Do Next
- 1From safety, save original scene or dashcam files showing the defect and direction of travel; write route, lane, cross street, mile or postmile where available.
- 2Keep vehicle or bicycle condition photos, repair documents, witnesses and the investigating agency’s report number.
- 3Identify the road controller using official maps or agency contacts; ask about complaints, inspection, work orders and repair history for the exact segment.
- 4Ask qualified counsel promptly which public-entity claim rules and deadlines apply to the actual event and entity.
Evidence Checklist
- Precise route, direction, lane, landmark or postmile and dated original images
- Official road-jurisdiction map or written agency confirmation
- Complaint, inspection, work-order and repair-request numbers, if obtainable
- Crash report, witness details and vehicle damage or injury records
Keep your unanswered questions handy when comparing the attorney’s public profile with your needs.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Filing or requesting records from Caltrans merely because a road looks like a highway
- Calling a later repair proof the agency knew of the defect before the incident
- Using a generic lawsuit deadline for a potentially applicable government-claim process
How the Process Typically Works
Fix the location
Preserve route, direction, lane and landmark details along with safely made original scene files.
Identify control
Check official road jurisdiction and record which state, local or private actor maintained the exact segment.
Trace notice and process
Separate earlier complaints and work from post-incident repairs; obtain individualized advice about the applicable claim process.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does a road repair prove the agency was at fault?
No. A repair after the incident is not the same as proof of the earlier condition, control, notice or causation. Preserve its date and look for records from before the event.
How can I identify a state-highway location?
Caltrans tools use route and postmile information. Note direction, lane and nearby landmarks as well, then confirm which agency controls the exact segment.
Is there one deadline for all road-defect claims?
No. California Government Code section 911.2 generally requires a claim for injury, death or personal-property damage against a public entity to be presented within six months after the claim accrues. The responsible entity, accrual date and possible exceptions need prompt individual review; this claim-presentation step is separate from filing a lawsuit.
Use the attorney’s public background as a starting point for a direct conversation about fit.
Related Resources
Free Intake Review
Share the basic facts and request help identifying an independent attorney who may be relevant
Secure intake request
Send your name and one way to reach you now. Case details are optional.
Important Disclosures
Attorney Advertising. Hurt Advice is a lawyer-referral and legal-information service, not a law firm. This website provides general information, not legal advice. Viewing a page or submitting a form does not create an attorney-client relationship. Independent participating attorneys decide whether to accept a matter, and representation begins only under a separate written agreement. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome; results depend on the facts and circumstances of each matter.